Tuesday, April 11, 2017

A Latter-Day Doris Day Fan 'Fesses Up

Doris Day was America's Sweetheart in movies for 20 years!

I confess. As an alleged cool ‘70s teen, I thought Doris Day was a dork. To me, Doris Day was like Debbie Reynolds, a middle-aged star who acted like a perky ingénue. I was allergic to their mugging in movies and cutesy charms on talk shows. As time went by, I learned more about their lives and careers. I came to appreciate both mid-century movie girls next door, but I’m writing here to sing the praises of Doris Day.

There are still sections of Doris Day’s career that I can only take in small doses. Doris Day and sweet go together like apple pie and ice cream, dished up by Hollywood. For me, watching Doris Day in her first WB musicals or later CBS TV show is like taking a big swig of fresh orange juice—right after brushing my teeth!

Doris gets a Warner Bros. makeover in 1948's  'Romance on the High Seas.'

The string of Warner Bros. musicals that started Doris’ career are pure saccharine. Doris is the 30-ish tomboy/ingénue, slathered in pancake makeup to hide the most famous freckles since Joan Crawford’s. Depending on the movie’s era, Doris sported frilly or silly costumes, wigs or her trademark DA ‘do. Watching these flicks, Doris Day reminds me of a singing and dancing kewpie doll. That’s just my personal taste. Still, Day is at the peak of her youth, energy, and bell-like voice—a saving grace--and the Warner/Day musicals are still fan favorites.

The Doris Day Show ran from 1968-73, her graceful segue from film. Many golden era big names had a hard time finding suitable film vehicles in New Hollywood. So stars like Doris, Debbie, Shirley MacLaine, Jimmy Stewart, Henry Fonda, and others headlined series built around them. Most of them failed—except Doris.

A perpetually sunny Day!
Cast members, locales, and plotlines changed each season, but Doris Day was always the same. Day was TV’s favorite career girl, after Marlo Thomas’ That Girl but before The Mary Tyler Moore Show. Day was over 15 years older than either of THOSE career “girls.” But there was Doris, pushing 50, in false eyelashes and falls, high fashion and soft focus, working hard and fighting off the fellas! Me and my sister would roll our eyes and laugh at the sappiness—and we were in grade school. My mother always had a low tolerance for Day, calling her “Dodo.” Just hearing Day trill “Que Sera, Sera” over the opening credits was a siren song that sent my Mom out of the room or into a book. Watching clips online today, the show is even more absurd. Yet, I gotta say—Doris looks great! Plus, the show was hit, a testimony to Day’s devoted fan base.

Sunny Doris Day was a success as a movie and TV star.

In Doris’ fine memoir, co-written with A.E. Hotchner, Day was direct about those repetitious early WB roles and the studio’s cookie cutter house style. Later, Day found herself tied to a husband, instead of a studio head. Thanks to her producer hubby, Doris not only lost her money, but was committed for the schlocky TV series, which she found out about after his sudden death. My opinion of Doris Day the person changed after I read her straightforward book.

Doris was a top film star for 20 years, with no long climb to the top, no slow downward slide. She was a popular big band singer for a decade when Warner Bros. biggest director, Michael Curtiz, deemed Day the ideal “all-American girl.” Curtiz starred her in his next movie, 1948’s Romance on the High Seas. Day won audiences’ hearts right from the start.

Doris as a '50s movie and musical fave!
The singer-actress’ music career continued to soar. A Billboard poll of the country’s top DJs voted Doris Day the top female singer 9 years out of 10 during the 1950s. During her WB years, while her movie musicals were popular, but not yet blockbusters, their soundtracks were big sellers, a double dip of Doris Day bucks for Jack Warner’s studio.

Doris left WB in 1954, making the smart move to freelance. From there, she stretched her range with Love Me or Leave Me in ’55 and Hitchcock’s The Man Who Knew Too Much in ’56. At the end of the fifties, Doris Day struck superstar status with Pillow Talk. From there, Day did a string of sex comedies, mixed with the occasional musical. Despite the swiftly changing ‘60s, fans flocked to Doris Day movies through much of the decade.

Doris Day’s career had several phases—musical starlet, leading lady, comedic superstar—with fan favorites from each. Here are six of my favorite Doris Day films:
Frank & Doris w/Ethel Barrymore.
On the set of "Young at Heart."

Young at Heart. This1954 musical drama is Day’s last movie on her WB contract. What lifts this soap opera with songs is her pairing with Frank Sinatra, hot off his From Here to Eternity comeback. Is this a great film? No. It is highly entertaining, however. A great supporting cast is led by Ethel Barrymore. The story is a remake of the WB classic Four Daughters, with Frank’s bad boy singer/songwriter bonding with Day’s musical family. Doris and Frank are at their musical best. Sinatra’s spice is a savory mix with Day’s sweetness, which also blended well with Debbie Reynolds the next year, in The Tender Trap.

Doris Day displays her tough side in this '55 musical drama.

Love Me or Leave Me. Musical film bios were all the rage in the ‘50s and this is one of the best. It seems amazing that Doris Day didn’t get an Oscar nod for her applauded performance as ‘30s singer Ruth Etting, controlled by a crazy mobster, played by James Cagney. But MGM put all their musical marbles with Susan Hayward for I’ll Cry Tomorrow. Plus, Eleanor Parker also scored an Oscar nom in Interrupted Melody that year. Still, it may be the only movie Day played where her edge shows. Doris sings all the old songs in a sassy, stylized style and acts up a helluva storm against one of WB’s greatest gangstas.

A happy family in a Hitchcock movie? Think again!

The Man Who Knew Too Much. This ’56 Alfred Hitchcock picture is epic entertainment; Doris gets another classic leading man, Jimmy Stewart.  They play a vacationing couple in Morocco, where doc Jimmy hears a murdered man’s last words. When their son is kidnapped to ensure Stewart’s silence, it becomes torture for the film’s couple and taut suspense for audiences. Doris Day makes a fine Hitchcock blonde, with that all-American sex appeal Hitch loved. Day initially found his lack of direction toward her work puzzling. Hitchcock’s response was he didn’t need to, because she was doing fine!

Doris Day sold movies & soundtracks in her heyday.
The Pajama Game. Thanks to smart direction by Stanley Donen, snappy choreography by Bob Fosse, this 1957 musical is still as fresh and fun as ever. Based on the Broadway hit, it teams Doris with the original cast. Rare for a musical, there’s actually a story, too. Day is in fine form here, as the Union leader determined to get her co-workers their raise. There’s a ton of fun tunes, but Day’s rendition of “Hey, There” is right up there with her other signature songs.

America's Sweetheart & The King.

Teacher’s Pet. This ’58 comedy teamed Day with The King, Clark Gable. Doris and Clark have a nifty rapport as a journalism teacher tangling with an old school reporter, who thinks teaching news is a bunch of hooey. A great cast and smart dialogue make this smooth fun.

Pillow Talk. The 1959 classic re-wrote the playbook for romantic comedies. Pillow Talk was considered risqué in its time, with its plot of party line hang-ups and hook-ups. Doris is the career woman and Rock is the randy wolf. Backed by a great cast, racy dialogue, plus stylish clothes, sets, and photography, Pillow Talk made Doris Day a bonafide superstar. This is Day’s biggest-grossing movie ever, and it gave Doris her only Oscar nomination.

Doris Day with Rock on the set of 'Pillow Talk,' their game-changing comedy.

After Pillow Talk, Day reteamed with Rock twice more, and starred in fluffy comedies opposite some of Hollywood’s biggest male stars: Cary Grant, David Niven, Rex Harrison, Rod Taylor, and James Garner. Doris played well with all of them. Day’s box office ride cruised on autopilot until 1967. This was a defining year in ‘60s cinema, after Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf and Bonnie and Clyde broke the censorship mold. Day’s last couple films were disappointments, when she just stopped, after nearly 40 movies, in 1968. Out of those movies, only a handful lost money—an incredible achievement.

It’s a shame that somebody couldn’t convince Doris to take up the offer of Mrs. Robinson in 1967’s The Graduate.  To me, it would have been the next logical step after Pillow Talk. Yes, it’s hard to imagine anyone but Anne Bancroft playing the rich bitch housewife. Nothing against Annie! However, Day would not have been improbable. In the novel version of The Graduate, the characters are all yuppie, smiling California blondes. I think that if Doris had shed or spun her image, under Mike Nichols’ direction, Mrs. Robinson could have done for Doris Day what Virginia Woolf did for Elizabeth Taylor.

Doris Day, are you trying to seduce us?
Hear me out. Doris Day is by all accounts a nice woman, but you don’t survive as a band singer on the road for a decade, in Hollywood for two decades, and on television another decade, without having a tough side. And letting that side show comically could have opened a whole new career for Doris Day.

Whatever the reasons, Doris chose not to play Mrs. Robinson. And when you look back on her vast work and cultural impact, Day didn’t have to. Doris Day left Hollywood on a high note and has lived a peaceful life with her many dogs and close friends in Carmel, CA. She turned 97 on April 3, 2019 with her usual low-key birthday party, waving to her loyal fans who made the pilgrimage to pay homage to their adored Doris. In retrospect, a lovely farewell from Doris Day, who died of pneumonia May 13, 2019. Cheers to Doris Day, for a life well-lived, and for keeping the world in good cheer for so many decades. 
So, here’s to you, Doris Day. Some fans loved you more than they ever knew.

Here's one of DD's best, IMO--Stanley Donen's The Pajama Game! My look: 
And here's my take on DD & Cary Grant at the height of their mature appeal: 

Doris Day at age 54 on Johnny Carson's show in 1976.
Doris had better bod than most of Hollywood's sex symbols!

FYI: I put all the movie overflow on my public FB  movie page. 

Check it out & join!  https://www.facebook.com/groups/178488909366865/


  1. I enjoyed reading what you wrote about Doris, but I love everything she has ever done in movies, TV and in music. I love and idolize her and I am a lifelong fan. I admire her most of all for her devotion to saving animals.

  2. Patricia,
    One of things I admire about Doris Day is how devoted her fans are...says a lot! DD is one of those performers that I got to like better as time went by. And I love that Doris left Hollywood on a high note and loves life in Carmel!
    Cheers, Rick

  3. Agree with everything you write about Doris, Rick. As much as I love her, I can't abide watching anything she did in the "little Dutch girl bob haircut" phase.

    Teacher's Pet is a family favorite which my sisters and I can quote verbatim. It doesn't bither me a bot. She has a great sight gag in her swoon after Gable kisses her the first time. Also watching her mimic Mamie Van Doren is hysterical.

    I could watch Pillow Talk every week. It's that delicious! And she looks gorgeous! No one in Hollywood has ever had a better figure! The moment in the nightclub when the camera and Rock Hudson watch her backside is a classic!

    And I vividly remember that appearance on the Tonight Show when it was very clear she was not wearing a bra. And Johnny Carson knew it!

    Imagining her as Mrs. Robinson is intriguing. I would have loved to see her get a chance at a role like the mother in Ordinary People. Mary Tyler Moore was terrific, but I could easily see Doris knocking it out of the park!

    Thanks for a sunny walk down memory lane!

  4. Hey Roberta, Teacher's Pet used to be on the afternoon movie all the time, and we loved it too! As for that Carson appearance, Johnny was definitely attracted!

    Interesting connection between Doris and Mary. Both America's sweethearts, but both had tough starts and were single moms for a while. And underneath the fluff was definitely some steel.
    Great women!

  5. Great article on one of my very favorite stars, Rick, and I felt exactly the same way you did about her until I read the Hotchner book - then I was hooked and in love! Agreed, her best roles were in Love me or Leave Me, Man Who Knew Too Much, and (in my opinion) Midnight Lace and Julie. I never cared for the Warner musicals - or for the sex comedies either, believe it or not. I do need to see Young at Heart one of these days - it is very hard to find.

    Thanks as always for your wonderful articles - and the amazing photos you always find.


    1. Hi Chris, I just happened to come across Young at Heart on YouTube. It's in 4 or 5 segments, but the print is clear and sound good. Check it out! Rick

  6. Hi Chris, there are bits here and there I enjoy of Doris' WB movies or later sex comedies, but usually they are very one-note and sugar-sweet for me. That said, I always got a kick out of The Glass Bottom Boat. Frank Tashlin had some fun with the DD formula. That Touch of Mink is watchable mainly to see Doris with Cary Grant. But many are a blur to me!

    But I think Doris Day had the potential to do anything, much like Judy Garland!

    Cheers, and thanks for your thoughts!
    Follow me if you haven't already : )

  7. Your assessment of Miss Day (and the way your appreciation for her grew after reading her book) is practically identical to my own! She is something of a spirit animal or guardian angel of sorts to many folks around me because she was born and raised about two miles from my house! Though she never comes back, her legend is still in the air (of course, we also gave the world Roy Rogers and Charles Manson, so the spectrum is wide!! LOL) In any case, we feel a sense of loyalty and/or ownership towards her. I really, REALLY wanted her to come back to the screen when she won her Golden Globe lifetime achievement award and she said she was ready to, but it didn't happen. Still, we have all those movies and TV shows that have her sort of crystallized in time, hardly aging. As a dramatic sort of person, I was always more drawn to her in "The Man Who Knew Too Much" and the hoots "Julie" and "Midnight Lace" but I like her movies with Hudson a lot, too. It would have been awesome to see her tackle Mrs. Robinson and Mike Nichols would have ensured that she hit the right notes in the off-beat role, I'm sure.

    1. Well, Poseidon, now I am going to have to go do a search and see what YOU'VE written on DD...you're so dang prolific!

      Love the hometown connection...if you haven't written an appreciation on DD, maybe it's your turn : )

      By the way, I watched that Golden Globes lifetime clip. Clint Eastwood is so sweet to her, and she COULD have come back! And shame, shame, shame on the Academy for not giving a similar moment on their show.

      Thanks for reading and follow me if you don't already! Cheers, Rick

  8. Rick, the motion picture academy has offered Doris the honorary Oscar three times, and three times she has politely refused. Same with an AFI tribute. And a Kennedy Center award.

    1. Never heard that about the latter two honors. Regarding the honorary Oscar, I had read that she didn't want to attend, and the Academy wanted her there in person, sort of a stand off. Doris is so private these last decades, who can say?
      Cheers, Rick

  9. I’ve loved Doris Day since I was a child, I saw the glass bottom boat at the drive in. Her show on TV hopscotching on nob hill, coming down her spiral staircase singing Que Sera Sera......Her show was on after Here’s Lucy. So Monday nights, Lucy and Doris were my babysitters. I think she turned down awards because she did it already. She left for a beautiful life in Carmel Valley. And probably doesn’t want to be seen and criticized for being old, like Kim Novak was on a recent TV appearance. She worked since HighSchool in show business, I think she was glad to retire. Her home has a beautiful Pacific Ocean view. Full of animals, has a lovely hotel where you can bring your dog........she’s a class act and people love her for it. Everyone loves a nice dog and Doris does too!

    1. I think you're absolutely right! I'm glad her later years have been mostly peaceful ones. Thanks for writing!

  10. Replies
    1. Julie is a close second to Doris Day's screaming mimi mode! Hitchcock controlled that aspect in her better with 'The Man Who Knew To Much!'

  11. As far as velvet covering an iron core, i don't know if there's any better way to describe the Sainted Doris. When you compare her "image" to the, at times, horror show yhay life has chosen to send her way - AND, she's persevered, and gotten through to the other side, she's AMAZING! Unlike so many of you, i'm a lifelong fan, we had some sort of promo album, bright ref cover, with the prettiest lady i had ever seen. And then the music itself! i think that i was about 5 or 6 years old, and i've loved her ever since. And, back in high school,the 70's, i was somewhat of a hippie, as was my beau, and one of our first bonding experiences was revealing that we both liked Doris. And not ironically.
    As far as her acting, some of her films, i didn't see until i was in my 20's or so, but, "Love Me, Or Leave Me ",thrills me - her portrayal of Ruth Etting, as a conniving, scheming, hard edged person, must have been a shock for audiences. And she's amazing, her delivery of the line 'you don't tell me your sad stories. I won't tell you mine ',when it's obvious that she sold her heart to 'The Gimp',she's half way to drunk, and her anger is just simmering, and just barely contained. It sends shivers down my spine.
    In other words, i love Doris Day, and i look forward to her little birthday appearances on her balcony each year! God(dess) bless Dodo!

    1. As I've said, I've come to enjoy Doris over the year, and it makes me feel good that she's living a happy life in Carmel... she deserves it every day! Cheers, Rick

  12. I think your favorite Day films are the same as mine! I was especially happy to see The Pajama Game included.

    I've been watching Day's TV show intermittenly for the past year or so since it's on Amazon Prime, and I must admit she is the primary reason why I keep watching. I like other aspects, like Rose Marie and the fashion, but I wouldn't classify it as a classic.

    Thanks for participating in my blogathon!

  13. Always found DD stupendously boring, but your piece was not. Congrats. Was wondering what happened to her.

  14. I adore Doris Day. One of the most underrated comedic actresses in Hollywood. And I’m so glad you mentioned Teacher’s Pet. hilarious, but with a lot to say. She could do anything. Another favorite is Calamity Jane!

    1. Doris was very natural on camera for both comedy and drama. Also, I review Teacher's Pet and another fave, The Pajama Game. Check them out! Cheers, Rick